Saiyaara, directed by Mohit Suri and starring debutants Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda, is being widely recognized as a return to classic Bollywood romance, with both its strengths and its familiar trappings.
Story & Emotional Core:
The film tells the heartbreak-driven story of Vaani Batra (Aneet Padda), abandoned on her wedding day, and Krish Kapoor (Ahaan Panday), an angry, aspiring musician. Their paths cross, leading to a partnership in music and eventual romance. Tragedy strikes in the form of illness and personal demons, testing the endurance of their love. As multiple reviews point out, the story is not novel and leans heavily on Bollywood’s well-worn “star-crossed lovers” and “tragic romance” tropes reminiscent of Suri’s previous films like Aashiqui 2 and even compares in tone to Sanam Teri Kasam.
Despite the predictable arc, Saiyaara succeeds in making these tropes emotionally resonant for many viewers, resulting in a heartfelt and immersive viewing experience.
Performances & Chemistry:
- Ahaan Panday’s debut is widely praised for its conviction, rawness, and energy, with some reviewers hailing it as one of Bollywood’s most promising debuts in years. He is compared to Ranbir Kapoor’s Rockstar and even to a young Ranveer Singh.
- Aneet Padda is lauded for her vulnerability, warmth, and ability to balance pain and resilience. The chemistry between the two leads is cited as a major highlight, with their shared silences and glances delivering as much as their dialogues.
Music:
The soundtrack has been one of the film’s biggest draws, with multiple composers contributing to music that captures the emotional highs and lows. Tracks like the eponymous “Saiyaara” are integrated seamlessly into the narrative, amplifying the film’s impact.
Direction & Execution:
Mohit Suri, known for his affinity with tragic love stories, delivers a film that’s technically slick, emotionally charged, and targeted at young audiences. His direction ensures the familiar feels fresh enough, focusing on the vulnerability of the male protagonist and contemporary dilemmas.
Criticism & Weaknesses:
- The plot’s predictability and reliance on clichés are called out in nearly every review. There are no surprises, and sometimes the melodrama feels over the top.
- The film can feel “burdened with the heaviness of its own imagined poignancy,” and the screenplay’s familiarity makes it less appealing to those seeking novelty in storytelling.
- Some emotional beats are seen as needlessly prolonged or overdramatic.
Summary Table: Saiyaara Review Highlights
| Aspect | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|
| Story | Emotional, relatable, classic tragic romance | Predictable, cliché, heavily inspired by earlier films |
| Performances | Ahaan Panday’s standout debut; strong chemistry with Padda | Some acting moments overdramatic |
| Music | Soulful soundtrack, integrated into narrative | None significant |
| Direction | Mohit Suri’s trademark emotional style, polished visuals | Sometimes excessive in melodrama |
| Audience Appeal | Resonates with youth, especially Gen-Z & college crowd | Potentially too familiar for older audiences |
Critical Consensus:
Saiyaara is praised for reviving the Bollywood romance, riding on the charm and chemistry of its leads and a memorable soundtrack. While the plot rehashes familiar tropes, its emotional depth, music, and earnest performances make it a crowd-pleaser, especially for those seeking a classic, heart-wrenching love story on the big screen.
How does Saiyaara compare to Mohit Suri’s previous tragic romances like Aashiqui 2
Comparison: Saiyaara vs. Aashiqui 2
Core Themes & Storytelling
- Familiar Tragic Romance Structure: Both Saiyaara and Aashiqui 2 are centered around star-crossed lovers, heartbreak, and the toll that personal demons take on romance. They rely on Bollywood’s classic tragic love story blueprint—young love blossoming under challenging circumstances, with tragedy as a defining climax.
- Predictability vs. Novelty: Saiyaara is especially noted for echoing the beats of Aashiqui 2: abandoned love, musical ambition, and emotional turmoil. However, most reviewers agree that while Aashiqui 2 felt fresh at its release, Saiyaara feels more derivative, with critics pointing out that Mohit Suri’s narrative formula is now recognizable and somewhat expected.
Lead Performances & Chemistry
- Impactful Debuts: Aashiqui 2 revitalized Aditya Roy Kapur’s and Shraddha Kapoor’s careers with memorable, emotionally raw performances and potent on-screen chemistry. Similarly, Saiyaara is praised for Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda’s debut performances, which are described as heartfelt and vulnerable. Both pairs of leads deliver chemistry that elevates their films beyond clichéd writing.
- Characterization: While Aashiqui 2 focused more on the male protagonist’s self-destruction and its impact on love, Saiyaara attempts to balance both protagonists’ struggles, giving equal emotional weight to their journeys.
Music & Soundtrack
- Signature Musical Integration: Both films are lauded for their music, with the soundtracks becoming cultural touchstones. Songs are central to forwarding the narrative and amplifying the emotional resonance. Aashiqui 2‘s soundtrack became iconic, and Saiyaara’s “Saiyaara” title track follows a similar trajectory, achieving popularity before the film’s release and deepening its on-screen moments.
Direction & Execution
- Stylistic Consistency: Mohit Suri’s signature is clear in both films: lush visuals, melodramatic flourishes, and a focus on youthful, intense love. However, critics of Saiyaara note that while the execution remains polished, Aashiqui 2 had a sense of urgency and freshness, whereas Saiyaara sometimes feels burdened by its own emotional weight and predictability.
Critical Reception & Audience Appeal
| Aspect | Saiyaara | Aashiqui 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Story | Classic tragic romance, feels derivative | Fresh at release, now a genre benchmark |
| Lead Performances | Strong debuts, palpable chemistry | Breakthrough, soulful performances |
| Music | Standout soundtrack, Gen-Z appeal | Iconic, genre-defining songs |
| Direction | Polished, emotionally charged, melodramatic | Innovative for the time, set template for successors |
| Audience Appeal | Youth/Gen-Z, nostalgia for classic romance | Broad, including older and younger audiences |
Key Takeaways
- Saiyaara revisits the emotion-first, tragedy-laden template of Aashiqui 2, but with new leads and a contemporary sheen, targeting a younger audience.
- While both films are emotionally resonant, Saiyaara does not break new ground the way Aashiqui 2 did upon release—making it comforting yet less innovative for long-time fans of Mohit Suri’s romantic dramas.
The tickets for Saiyaara are available on BookmyShow and District.
For box office updates and more movie news, stay tuned to our Website AbsoluteCinema.in as we bring you the latest, always in simple words.